How There Can Be One Infinity Larger Than Another Infinity

70

By scramble

Introduction

Intuitively speaking, infinity goes on forever so it doesn't make much sense to us that you can add anything to infinity. Even if you could, isn't infinity just infinite? How can one be bigger than another? It is pretty counter intuitive but some clever stick by the name of George Cantor showed, in simple terms, how this can be so. This is actually very easy to follow and very elegant in my opinion.

Before we start, its important to set aside our preconception about what infinity is and what it is not. The majority of us learn a basic definition that our young minds can understand and this is what we tend to hold as true. However, infinity has been redefined over and over again throughout history. Along with zero, infinity remains one of the most counter intuitive concepts.


The Proof: A Layman's Version

Imagine an infinite string of 2 arbitrary characters. We will use a and b.

Here is an example of such a string...

aababbaaababbbabababbabbbababab...........(and so on)

Furthermore, imagine an infinite number of these unique strings. No string is exactly the same; it is easy to comprehend that there can be an infinite number of these strings.

I will start a few for illustrative purposes. I have just randomly selected as and bs by arbitrarily, and rapidly hitting those keys.

abababababbbababbbabaaaababababababab...
bbababbababababababbabbababbababbabab...
aabbababbababababbababababaaababaabab...
aababaabababababbbabababaabbabbababab...
.............................................................................
...these strings go on "forever."

Now, lets select a string made up of the 1st character from the first string, the 2nd character from the 2nd row, the nth character from the nth row...
(nth basically means that you can pick any number you like to be n)

abababababbbababbbabaaaababababababab...
bbababbababababababbabbababbababbabab...
aabbababbababababbababababaaababaabab...
aababaabababababbbabababaabbabbababab...
......................................................................................

Now, of the string selected, lets flip the characters so that every a becomes a b and every b becomes an a.

bbababababbbababbbabaaaababababababab...
baababbababababababbabbababbababbabab...
aaabababbababababbababababaaababaabab...
aabbbaabababababbbabababaabbabbababab...
......................................................................................

It is now easy to see that this new string must be unique within our set of strings: It differs from the 1st string by its 1st character; it differs from the 2nd string by its 2nd character; it differs from the nth string by its nth character.

So we can always add another unique string to our already infinite set of strings. Therefore, we have one infinite set bigger than another infinite set! That means there must be one infinity larger than another.

Comments

Snah 22 months ago

I'm probably missing something but does that just mean that there is one more difrent infinity?

scramble profile image

scramble Hub Author 22 months ago

There is not only one more but infinitely many more! Crazy stuff eh!?

manofthewill profile image

manofthewill 13 months ago

Infinity equals "everything", zero equals "nothing".

Was this intuitive?

Innocent 11 months ago

WHAT IS WRONG WITH MOST PEOPLE BRAINS THAT THEY GET ON CONFUSED WITH ACTUAL INFINITY.INFINITY JUST CONSTRAINTS YOU TO NOT ABLE O MEASURE IT, BUT YOU COULD MAKE IT MORE BIGGER BY ADDING MORE ON IT.

logic 3 months ago

Infinity mean "Never ending"

So if A is bigger than B, then B is NOT an infinity as it has definable boundary's, therefore B is NOT an infinity.

Some twit may have used clever word/math games to come up with this nonsense but simple basic logic proves the originator is an idiot

Phineas Delgado 11 days ago

This is false. If we move on the assumption that an infinite number of 2-digit strings exists, then the strings "created" by the swapping of digits as described would already exist within the "infinite" frame work.

"Infinite" by definition means that all possible combinations of the two digit strings exist. An exchange of digits like the one shown only moves strings from one position in the scheme to another (since duplication isn't allowed).

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working